MuhVerisimilitude
Adventurer
Because "it wouldn't be realistic to have an ability that isn't magical that can do X reliably".N the nerf tge wizard threa Silvery barbs came and that reminded me why I dislike that spell in the end its using a reaction to distract a target (within 60 ft) and having yourself or any ally use that distraction for advantage, why can’t a Fighter do that too?
Some people believe, or argue anyway, that the only way to do something reliably is by using magic. If it's not magic it can't be reliable.
They'll argue for this by trying to point out edge cases. For example they might argue that "distracting" someone is not something that a person can do because every individual is always in 100% control of their own behavior and they must not be forced to make a particular choice.
They might argue that certain creatures must be immune to this effect, since the effect isn't magical.
This is how you have people legitimately arguing that it should never be possible to have a character so scary that their enemies run in panic. Because that, according to them, should require a magical effect.